Back to Blog   Back to Blog
Posted on 10 Aug 2026

Margherita to Meat Lovers: Our Favorite Colorado Pizza

In a mountain town, few things hit the spot quite like a good pizza, especially after a long travel day or an epic one spent skiing, hiking, biking, or just soaking up the alpine air. It's the ultimate comfort food and perfect for either a night in or casual dinner out. We asked our team to dish on their favorite local pizza joints—whether it’s for dining in, grabbing takeout, or having it delivered. From traditional classics to seasonal creations, here are the pies we crave the most!


Steamboat

"Brooklynn's in Steamboat. Go for The Max!"
Diana Crowley, Guest Services Manager

"Great for late night slices with free delivery after 5pm. The Max is a great option to feed the entire family!.
Vanessa Beasley, Guest Services & Content Specialist

Since 1996, Brooklynn’s Pizzeria has been a favorite among Steamboat Springs locals and visitors, serving pizza made with fresh ingredients and dough prepared daily. Open seven days a week from 11 a.m. until midnight, it is a convenient spot for lunch, dinner, or a late night slice.


"In Steamboat, Blue Sage and the Full Boat or Jalapeno Popper"
Erik Skinner, 

"My vote for Pizza in SBT is Blue Sage, for dine in and carry out."
Lisa Riniker, Director of Operations

Serving Steamboat since 1992, Blue Sage Pizza is a local spot for hand tossed, thin crust, and deep dish pizzas. Guests can dine in, grab pizza by the slice, order to go, or choose delivery.


Breckenridge

"Giampietro Pizza in Breckenridge, dine in or take out all day long!!!!!!!"
Nancy McDowell, Staff Accountant

"Giampietro's, NY style pizza, as a pizza purest I like cheese or pepperoni, for the more adventurous white pizza with tomato, basil and sausage!"
Christine Izard, Owner Relations Manager

Giampietro Pasta & Pizzeria is a downtown Breckenridge favorite serving pizza and Italian dishes for lunch and dinner. Open daily, the menu features pizzas, pastas, salads, and other Italian favorites, with dine in and takeout available.


"Casual, family-friendly and housemade pizza crust. Choose between traditional or thin crust, and the pies come in 3 sizes, perfect for feeding a big group."
Justin Saunders, Photographer

Fatty's Pizzeria & Sports Bar is a longtime Breckenridge favorite serving hearty portions made with fresh ingredients. The menu features housemade pizza, sandwiches, salads, pastas, wings, and other casual favorites for lunch and dinner.


Vail Valley

"Pazzo's is also great in Vail Village."
Chad Rowe, Chief Operating Officer

Pazzo's Pizzeria has been serving pizza and Italian food in the Vail Valley for more than 25 years. Its Vail location sits at the west end of the Vail Village parking structure and offers casual, family friendly dining in the heart of the village.


"Pick Ups Pizza Eagle ... their deep dish is delicious. And yes pineapple is 100% a pizza top tier topping. "
Mickael Chavy, General Manager 

"I second Mickael's pick, Pick Up Pizza in Eagle. Not sure about the pineapple topping though..meh."
Andrew Metzler, Business Development Sales Associate

Pickup's Pizza Company is a local pizza spot in Eagle serving fresh pizzas with dough made in house. The menu includes classic and specialty pizzas, including deep dish options, making it an easy choice for a casual pizza night in Eagle.


LET US HELP YOU FIND YOUR PERFECT STAY AT ONE OF OUR MANY HOMES IN STEAMBOAT SPRINGS, BRECKENRIDGE, VAIL, AND BEAVER CREEK.

FIND A RESIDENCE

Previous Margherita to Meat Lovers: Our Favorite Vail Valley Pizza